Big Fishing Creek Trophy Trout Section, Clinton Co, 7-14-18

Prospector

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 7, 2015
Messages
1,195
City
Butler Co home, Forest Co camp
Time Fished: 830am - 1100am
Weather Conditions: Sunny Clear, 75 - 80 degrees
Water Conditions: Clear, 58 degrees
Insects: Some Caddis, looked like some small BWO hatching between 830 & 900am,a few other lighter mayflies but just 1 or 2, at 10am a decent number of spinners dancing over the riffle (I thought they might be Tricos but they seemed too large, I couldn’t catch any). Despite the spinners obvious presence in a few riffles, they didn’t bring any trout to the surface.

We fished below the Tylersville hatchery. Overall not a lot of insects and all rising ended when the sun got fully on the water about 920. I caught 4 small browns on a sz 16 Tan Caddis and lost a few others.

After 920am, when the trout stopped rising, I worked 2 separate riffles with the same tan caddis without bringing up a fish. This really was surprising. Caught 4 trout in first 20 minutes, then failed to even bring up a fish to look at the fly for the last 90 minutes. Seemed like the bright sunny sky sent the trout into hiding.

We decided to pack up and try our luck at Fisherman’s Paradise with the hopes that some fish would be midging and we could change flies until we found the right one. Unfortunately it was no better. I saw no insects and maybe 7-8 rises. The nine guys I talked to got 0, 2, 0, 0, 1, 1, 0, 0. We fished from about 1230pm to 2pm. I decided to try something that other people may not have tried so I fished a caddis dry (brought one fish up but it didn’t take) and on a streamer I had one flash at it.

It was just one of those days. After catching 4 so quickly at Big Fishing Creek, I said to myself that I was on my way to double digits. So much for that but it was a fun day with friend and family.
 
Those spinners may have been paralepts.
I've often seen them on summer mornings.
But - as you saw today - they never seem to bring the fish up.

Did you try any terrrestrials?
Your surface action would have likely improved with them
 
I thought the “small BWOs” I saw hatching were likely paraleptophlebias, but I didn’t get any to hand to confirm. I really am not sure about the spinners.

After I made a first pass of the area where I caught the fish on a caddis, I came back thru there with a small black beetle but never even had a look. I chose that small size since the fish were smaller. I switched to a large black beetle thinking a larger meal may be more desirable but nothing was interested in it either.
I used that combo with good success on Spruce Creek 2 wks ago (locate with humpy and catch them on terrestrial) but 10 days ago on East Branch they took the caddis and not the terrestrial...same as today.
 
This photo was not taken yesterday on BFC (because I could not catch one there) but it shows the insect we are discussing. This came from Neshannock Creek last June. On Neshannock the Para's hatch the same time as the small BWOs and there is 1 Para for every 2 BWOs. Both are sz 18 or 20. The common name is Blue Quill
 

Attachments

  • Paraleptophlebia from Nesh Creek.jpg
    Paraleptophlebia from Nesh Creek.jpg
    71.3 KB · Views: 10
Those blue quills are pretty common on BFC during the summer. The spinners often swarm all summer long.
 
Back
Top