Big Fishing Creek, Clinton County, 12/29-30/2023

discomidge

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 13, 2021
Messages
359
City
Lewisburg
I hit the BFC narrows yesterday and today. I'm quarantined away from my family with covid and fortunately it's not bad enough to keep me off the water. Beats bowl games full of second string players by a mile.

The weather and fishing was pretty similar both days so I'm not gonna write up individual cookie-cutter reports. Both days were partly cloudy and today spit a little. Air temps were mid 30s mid morning and rose to the mid 40s in the afternoon. There was a breeze both days that kicked up mid afternoon, nothing serious tho. I didn't temp the water, but it wasn't insanely cold - all hail the big Tylersville hatchery spring.

BFC is up and dirty, though it's clearing (today was noticeably clearer than yesterday). Visibility today was maybe 3' on average but varied in spots. It's about as high as I like to fish it which precludes some of my go-to wading opportunities, but for me at least that's a welcome trade off if it means there's some color in the water. Love BFC when it's colored up.

There wasn't much bug activity to speak of. Midges now and then and some tiny BWOs were around, but nothing in abundance. Yesterday I did see two violent, splashy rises, the only two rises I saw.

I euro nymphed both days. Yesterday I put in about 4.5 hours and caught 15 browns, but today I only lasted for 2.5 hours (stupid covid) and caught 2 browns and 2 brookies. Today I didn't fish as hard and spent most of my time exploring spots I don't regularly hit and eating a very large sub. I found a couple cool pools tucked way back in there and caught a stud in one of them. I'll be going back there. The sub was good too (PA's cheap sandwich game is unparalleled). Yesterday's fish were stacked up. I'd catch 3-4 fish in a 10' long section then nothing for a while. Also, some of my go-to skunk-busting spots weren't holding fish, or at least fish that wanted to eat what I was serving.

And as for what was on the menu, I wish I could say that all the tiny midges, perdigons, and iron lotuses that normally produce out there for me were what took fish, but no. I tried them all, but every fish I caught ate an egg. Whatever, trout eat eggs as my brother says. He never fishes eggs.

Speaking of eggs, there are lots or redds out there, beware. I didn't see fish on them tho.

Here are some pics of some fish I bumped into. Every time I'm on BFC, I'm reminded that it's full of absolute 10/10 lookers. No notes.


stud.jpeg


extra magenta.jpeg

ooh shiny.jpeg

a real chode.jpeg

all the spots.jpeg
 
Very nice. Hope ya feel better.

Funny you mention about BFC fish being prettier than normal. I’ve often thought the genetics in that stream are somewhat unique. Lots of red undertones on BFC fish, and very vibrant red spots.

If you didn’t say where you caught those fish my first guess would have been BFC.
 
Thanks Swattie.

And yeah, I totally agree on the unique (and identifiable) look to BFC browns. I'm always stunned by those bright red spots and the bright white rings around them. They really pop on BFC, more so than other local streams. I'd love to know why that is.
 
Thanks for the write up. I was considering a trek up there in the next few weeks and was wondering how it was fishing.
 
I've only fished BFC narrows one time in my life. I caught four not very big browns, but they were distinctly vibrant looking fish. This is one of them. I will have to get back there, hopefully this summer.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0222.JPEG
    IMG_0222.JPEG
    182.7 KB · Views: 40
Hope you feel better. That second brown is beautiful! Nice write up! Thanks for posting. Any brookie photos?
 
Nice report. Good to know the Brook Trout are there too. Whenever I caught Brook Trout there they would be in pods. That creek holds many fond memories. When it turns on it can be very good. I spent a summer as a teenager living and working at the federal fish hatchery there. Don't know if that place is even still in operation.
 
That is a pretty awesome day on that section! Nice report, too. I must have driven past you going the WRONG direction on Thursday.... Cricks in your neck of the woods were pretty blown out. It seemed to get better in Centre County, but I should have gone north! Caught some fish, including a brookie in a Centre County spring creek, but it was tough....
 
That is a pretty awesome day on that section! Nice report, too. I must have driven past you going the WRONG direction on Thursday.... Cricks in your neck of the woods were pretty blown out. It seemed to get better in Centre County, but I should have gone north! Caught some fish, including a brookie in a Centre County spring creek, but it was tough....
I'll probably be out there tomorrow. I'll light the PAFF bat-signal in case you're passing by.
 
Very nice. Hope ya feel better.

Funny you mention about BFC fish being prettier than normal. I’ve often thought the genetics in that stream are somewhat unique. Lots of red undertones on BFC fish, and very vibrant red spots.

If you didn’t say where you caught those fish my first guess would have been BFC.
It’s about what they eat for the most part, then dna.
 
Back
Top