Best non-Trout Fish Caught while Trout Fishing?

Joined
Feb 15, 2024
Messages
34
City
South Central Pa
Interested if anyone wants to share any stories or pics of non-trout species surprisingly caught while trout fishing in PA?

I got a striper on the lower Brodhead (excuse the plug it was before fly fishing enlightenment) and a jumbo fall fish on Pine.

From Manchester VT, cheers guys.
B43891D3-C8D6-4878-A030-0520429F6223.png
 

Attachments

  • 10FD52C1-62F4-4F35-ABAD-FF76229CB820.png
    10FD52C1-62F4-4F35-ABAD-FF76229CB820.png
    818 KB · Views: 23
Not the best but the oddest was a pickerel on an egg fly.

Numerous large suckers , ~3 lb SMB, and a few shad on wets and/or nymphs; Most memorable was a large carp on a dry fly. A Lt. Cahill if memory serves.
 
A pike on 5x and yellow perch are always fun. River chub.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2224.jpeg
    IMG_2224.jpeg
    271.5 KB · Views: 9
  • IMG_8180.jpeg
    IMG_8180.jpeg
    196.4 KB · Views: 10
Top