Sunglasses for fly fishing?

S

skeeter bite

Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2022
Messages
34
Location
North Central Pennsylvania
I'm in the market for a good pair of prescription sunglasses that will help me see well into the water on the streams when fishing but will also work for driving, etc.
I'd like to hear about any sunglasses that some of you may use that have been exemplary. Thanks.
 
Best deals I've found have been at Zenni, and online eyeglass store.
Huge selection. And the quality has been quite good too
 
Que pcray
 
Whatever you decide on getting, my first recommendation is to not buy any pair of glasses before trying them on to ensure they fit and you like the frame style.
Some of the major companies that sell online will send you the frames beforehand to try them on, however, I’ve done that in the past and then later found that when my prescription (in glass, not polycarbonate) was later added to the frame that they became uncomfortably heavy. So I’ve subsequently used only polycarbonate glasses.

I used Smith Optics sunglasses for fishing for many years, as many others still do, and they supplied quality glasses, but over time they narrowed their selections of frames that they would put my particular bifocal prescription in to the point that nothing that they offered suited me.

About 6-8 years ago I switched to using Costa Del Mar sunglasses. The first pair that I got were pretty expensive, around $700.00 or so. The last 2 pair I got through my local optician (who is a Costa del Mar dealer) I was able to buy a discontinued model Costa frame, that I really liked, and then the optician sent it to his lab (not to Costa) for the prescription glasses. I think they are every bit as good as Costa’s, but at about half the cost.

If you’re not too fussy about the frame style and glass tints, but want reasonably good optics at an economical price, Costco also offers prescription sunglasses.

John
 
I went with America's Best as a cost saver. Around 300 bucks for Ray Ban Wayfarer frames and polarized lenses at their darkest tint.
 
Que pcray
Lol.

Obviously polarized. And avoid photochromic polarized (polarization isn't as good).

But in the Rx world things are more complicated, for sure. First, pretty much nobody does glass. Your prescription is probably going to lock you into a material, and they will all be some variety of plastic (poly, trivex, etc). Second, your prescription will also limit you to which frames are available. If you are a high Rx, you may not be able to get a wrap style lens, may not be able to get a large lens, etc. Third, some shops make their own lenses. They might sell you a pair of costa's or Smith's, however, what you just picked out was a frame. And the shop itself might make their own lenses to fit that frame. Very hit or miss depending on the quality of that lab. Ironically, some of the smaller shops may be better (but more $$$) because they don't make their own lenses, they will send the prescription out to Costa or Smith to have done at their lab, and those places do consistently good work (not to say a local shop can't do just as well, but again, it's hit or miss).

I do believe MJ is either alone or one of only a few that requires that their lab do the Rx lenses for their frames. A MJ dealer isn't allowed to make their own lenses and put it in an MJ frame. They are consistently regarded as THE most advanced, highest quality lab for Rx sunwear. But, the price might make ya blush. And nobody is saying you can't role the dice and get nearly as good quality at a 3rd of the price from Joe Schmoe's optical who buys polarized blanks from Essilor or someone like that, then grinds, tints, cuts, and coats his own lenses in his own lab. It depends on whether Joe buys high quality blanks, how good his equipment is, what your prescription is, and what frame you chose. If you have a relatively light prescription, and choose a small, fairly flat lens, and ask for anti-glare coatings, scratch coatings, etc., and Joe's equipment is modernized, his lab might make an amazing lens for you rivaling anything out there at a downright good cost. But spending the dime and getting it through MJ, if you can, takes away the gambling factor, you know it's going to be top of the line, and they'll probably be more willing to do something a little harder, like a really high Rx in a wrap, and do it well. Same would be true with Smith, Costa, etc. if you demand that the optician send it to Smith, Costa, etc. to make the lens (and he'll be like, ok, that's 3x the price).
 
Last edited:
As for buying glasses on line:

I was leery at first about doing that.
However the Zenni site has a slick feature that enables you to see how the glasses would fit and look on your face, that worked pretty well.
They also tell you how to measure your pupilary distance, which helps ensure a good fit.

I've bought several pair from them , and am quite happy with them.

My eye doctor even - surprisingly - told me that its a good place to buy glasses
 
We've been able to get along with reasonably-priced polarized lenses (w/o prescription since we wear contacts). I don't trust myself to not lose > $100 sunglasses so I don't buy them. Prescription lenses, always being especially pricey with additional "options", be sure to include a good positive-capture method so they don't fall off when you're waist-deep in moving water (or so you don't fling them off your face while swatting at blackflies).
 
We've been able to get along with reasonably-priced polarized lenses (w/o prescription since we wear contacts). I don't trust myself to not lose > $100 sunglasses so I don't buy them. Prescription lenses, always being especially pricey with additional "options", be sure to include a good positive-capture method so they don't fall off when you're waist-deep in moving water (or so you don't fling them off your face while swatting at blackflies).
I spend more than $100 on glasses and still lose them. I'm on my 4th pair of Costa's.
 
Whatever you decide on getting, my first recommendation is to not buy any pair of glasses before trying them on to ensure they fit and you like the frame style.
Some of the major companies that sell online will send you the frames beforehand to try them on, however, I’ve done that in the past and then later found that when my prescription (in glass, not polycarbonate) was later added to the frame that they became uncomfortably heavy. So I’ve subsequently used only polycarbonate glasses.

I used Smith Optics sunglasses for fishing for many years, as many others still do, and they supplied quality glasses, but over time they narrowed their selections of frames that they would put my particular bifocal prescription in to the point that nothing that they offered suited me.

About 6-8 years ago I switched to using Costa Del Mar sunglasses. The first pair that I got were pretty expensive, around $700.00 or so. The last 2 pair I got through my local optician (who is a Costa del Mar dealer) I was able to buy a discontinued model Costa frame, that I really liked, and then the optician sent it to his lab (not to Costa) for the prescription glasses. I think they are every bit as good as Costa’s, but at about half the cost.

If you’re not too fussy about the frame style and glass tints, but want reasonably good optics at an economical price, Costco also offers prescription sunglasses.

John
Is the difference from polycarbonate to glass really that much of a weight difference? I know glass is heavier I just don't think it would be heavier to be really noticeable (I have both glass and poly and can't tell much of a difference in weight). With today's advancements in polycarbonate they appear to be just as good in terms of the clarity in glass. I prefer glass for the added clarity.
 
Is the difference from polycarbonate to glass really that much of a weight difference? I know glass is heavier I just don't think it would be heavier to be really noticeable (I have both glass and poly and can't tell much of a difference in weight). With today's advancements in polycarbonate they appear to be just as good in terms of the clarity in glass. I prefer glass for the added clarity.
Glass lens are significantly heavier than polycarbonate lens.
 
Thanks for all the replies. I decided to order a pair of Wiley X sunglasses, placed the order yesterday. I bought them from the same local optical place that did my prescription so hoping for good quality. They said the turn around time was about two weeks from Wiley X. The optometrist helped me put the order together, sizing, etc., to make sure I get a good fit. I was able to try on the frames I was ordering and I think that helped a lot.
 
Does anyone have a recommendation for non-prescription bifocal sunglasses? (they call them readers) I was thinking of buying Costa del Mar. They have a wide selection and they've been advertising to fishermen for a long time.
I have generally bought copper/amber lenses as they seem to be best for spotting fish. (Which I'm still terrible at anyway.)
 
Is the difference from polycarbonate to glass really that much of a weight difference?

Glass is significantly heavier. Not terrible in non RX, but when you start needing a thicker blank to handle prescription, it adds up quick. Also glass shatters so they're not exactly a good choice if sunnies double as safety glasses, like in sports.

As far as clarity, you may not notice it unless you have excellent vision. But poly kinda sucks. That said, there are plastics that rival glass and are more common in higher end sunglasses. Not all plastic is poly. CR39, Trivex, and others. Many makes give their own marketing names to these plastics. "Maui Pure" and such.

Glass has a significant advantage in scratch resistance, and a scratch resistance coating on plastic doesnt make up for it. And glass takes anti glare coatings and the like better too.

Where glass shines for a fisherman is polarization. You can sandwich a high quality polarizing filter in anything. But, all plastics when under stress alter the polarization angle of light. It doest matter how good the polarizing film is if its blocking good light and not the reflections its supposed to. High quality plastic lenses do their best to reduce stress by injection molding instead of stamping, and full frames instead of half frames. But I have never met a plastic lens from anyone that when tested showed consistency in the polarization angle its blocking. And I've never met a glass lens, from anyone, that didn't. It's a fairly easy at home test too.
 
Last edited:
I have a number of pairs of MJs. The ones I fish in the most are glass and yes they are no doubt heavier than the other plastic mjs. I only wear the glass to fish in, for everything else it's the polycarbonate. They make a big difference on the water and are worth the weight imho.
 
Go to a computer screen. Wear 1 pair of polarized glasses, it doesn't matter how good, these aren't being tested. Take the the "test" pair. Hold them at arms length (closer to the screen than to the glasses you are wearing). Rotate the test pair. You'll see the screen get blacked out.

If the test lenses are plastic, any plastic, you will see blotchiness, or perhaps a fade from top to bottom. Never even. You will especially see differences around stress points. This is where the quality kind of shines through if you compare a cheapo set to a good set of glasses. Not that the good ones are even. But, they deal with the inherent deficiences of plastic better. Both sides will be the same. They'll keep the worst of the stress points away from the middle of the lens where your eyes are. They'll be in more sturdy frames that don't twist and bend, so at least it stays consistent. But, that distortion is still there. It's not possible not to have it.

If the lenses are glass, it will become uniformly BLACK.

Stress in plastic alters the polarization angle of the light going through it. So those reflections that you are trying to block. Reflected light is polarized. The polarizing filter is rotated as such to block that particular angle of polarized light. But if there's a piece of plastic between the reflecting surface and the polarizing filter, then that polarization angle is altered before it gets to the filter, and it's not blocked.

It's the same phenomenon as seeing the checkerboard pattern in cars rear windows through polarized glasses. That glass has a thin plastic sheet sandwiched in it, to prevent shattering catastrophically. The glass gets tempered in a furnace. When done, it's taken out and lays on a tray to cool. What you are seeing is the pattern of the tray. When the soft glass is laid on the tray, the pressure of the tray puts pressure on that plastic, and you're seeing different stresses in the plastic, which polarize light differently. When the glass cools, it locks in that stress pattern. You'll see the pattern with both plastic and glass lensed sunglasses, but it will be more pronounced with glass lenses.
 
This is no BS: Go to the fishing section at Walmart. You'll find polarized sunglasses for $5. I have a few pairs that I've used on streams all over. (I made certain to pick the frame that fits over my regular eyeglasses) Give them a try, you'll agree.
 

Attachments

  • 20221207_215232.jpg
    20221207_215232.jpg
    75.6 KB · Views: 12
Does anyone have a recommendation for non-prescription bifocal sunglasses? (they call them readers) I was thinking of buying Costa del Mar. They have a wide selection and they've been advertising to fishermen for a long time.
I have generally bought copper/amber lenses as they seem to be best for spotting fish. (Which I'm still terrible at anyway.)
I picked up a pair of Ono's bifocal polarized glasses about 10 years ago on sale at an outlet store. Grey lenses, black frame; I don't remember the bifocal power but probably 1.5-2. I really didn't need them at the time, but boy have they been handy as my eyes got older and I started fly fishing and had to deal with those ridiculously thin lines, I mean tippets. They're what I wear when fly fishing. The Carabelle model is closest to what I have.

They were about $60 on sale if I remember correctly and are still available on Amazon for $100 in multiple powers, lens color, etc. Comes with a hard case & cleaning cloth.
 
Costa's. I have the Fantail's with 580P polarized polycarbonate copper silver mirror's, also prescription. My eye dr ordered them direct through Costa, took a few weeks to get but totally worth it. They are pricey but my glasses have served me well for about 2 years on this pair, and I had another pair for about 4 years before that.

Highly recommend Costa, and their products.
 
One important thing for me ius to get some type of wrap around style frame. If I wear flat lenses the reflection or light coming in from behind , around my face/head, really compromises my view.
 
Back
Top