I think either would handle 99%+ of the trout you run into in PA just fine. Just recently bought the Pursuit in the same size you're looking at. As far as trout I've only caught one 8" stocker Brookie with it so far, but I did take it warmwater fishing and landed a couple 15" range Fallfish (which pull harder than an equal size trout IMO) with it with no problem. I was fishing it with 5wt line, but it threw small BH Buggers just fine too. Sure a 20"+ trout or big Smallie is gonna be a handful, but they will be on pretty much any rod below a 6wt or so.
They're both good rods for the price...the big difference in the two is the action. The CT is a legit medium rod, and the Pursuit is more on the lines of a med/fast IMO (although Redington calls it fast). I'd cast them and base my decision on which action I'd liked better...they'll hold up in a similar fashion to bigger fish.