afishinado wrote:
“The thing I like about the Mustads are the color. I hate shiny silver, gold or those funny colored hooks.
HTH,
Maurice”
Now YOU’RE over-thinking things (like I usually do). The dark (black) colored mustads are probably more visible to the fish (dark vs. a light background). TMCs, for example, are a light brown / bronze color. Most fisherman look down at their light colored hook, leader, and fly line and see that it’s more visible against the bottom as a background – but the fish look up from the bottom into the light. On your next fishing trip, wade out and lie down in the water on the bottom, looking up like a fish, and you’ll see what I mean. (Take plenty of towels and a change of clothes when you do that though.)
I also I’ve read, but don’t believe that shiny objects are less visible because they reflect and take on the colors of the background. I have to check that one out. But I don’t believe that true from a practical standpoint. A shiny round or faceted moving object will flash in the water and not act as a mirror, IMO. I try to stay away from real shiny hook finishes, but I would amagine that at times, fish might be attracted to the flash as they are with beadhead and shiny materials on a fly.
Even if that were true about the color of Mustads being less visible, I don’t use them anymore for reasons I have posted before:
Brittle – break when snagged on the bottom, when pinching down the barb, or trying to bend them for certain patterns
Rust – rust in my fly box all the time
Sharpness – not near as sharp as other hooks
Barb – larger barb than TMC (better hook penetration and easier to pinch down with a smaller barb)
Rejects – many more unusable hooks than other brands in a pack
Dark color – more visible to fish
Mustads are cheaper, but when I factored in the rejects, and the broken and rusted hooks - I really wasn’t saving much money. My hook of choice is TMC, although there are other good hooks out there too.
Mustads are my Weinbrenners!
BTW Mo, what does “HTH” mean?