rrt wrote:
2. Normally at this point, I would go into a rant about kissing and telling on streams and how that causes many problems due to overcrowding, but I do not want to start one of those acrimonious discussions.
Like it or not, innovations in technology and communication impact our society in many ways. It's useless to fight against that, and many (particularly of my generation) would argue that it's also not really a fight worth waging. It's not called the "information age" for nothing, and eventually the culture of expecting the secrecy of many of the better streams will disappear. All of the chicken littles are also saying that the numbers of fly fishermen are declining, and the sport is doomed... which is it?
It is ridiculous to expect a beginner fly fisherman to ignore the available resources and to set out blindly to find streams. I'd be willing to bet that our forefathers hated that the newbies were out there spot burning with their newfangled topo atlases and telephone calls to fly shops too. Eventually, our culture must accept innovation.
The fear of modern information exchange bears no fruit, rather we need to accept new directions that the sport is taking. I'd be willing to guarantee that finding solitude will not be a problem in my lifetime. If the claims about drastically declining numbers of fishermen are true, I've also got no fears for my children having the ability to find the same... as long as they don't use strike indicators when they do it.
I subscribe to the jackm theory of information exchange. If I tell the world about a new spot and they all go there, then by default, there will be other waters that will have fewer anglers. The only cases in which I'll hide information are when a) someone asks me to keep a secret that they've let me in on, and b) if the stream literally cannot stand the pressure for ecological reasons.
If it's not "spot burning", then it's just "bragging". Some people just like to complain.
Edit:
I should add that the hording of information is the absolute worst way to ensure our numbers for the future. Call it spoon feeding if you want, but the culture is changing. If we want people to be interested, we've got to attempt to help them to succeed. Any other viewpoint, in my opinion, is just selfishness under the familiar headings of "the most enjoyable part is searching for new water." While I may agree with that, not everyone does. If we want people to break into the sport, we can't force them to conform to that, especially given the proliferation of posting and development around our streams.