I have an orvis battenkill bar stock in a size II for 3-5 wt on my 4 wt. rod. It is a great reel. It looks good, has a good drag, and is very light weight. I think you would probably want the next size up, which is $119 on the orvis site. You could check ebay and might be able to find a deal or you could downsize to the reel I have which is only 2 and 3/4". Also, before I had the orvis reel, I had a Cabelas Prestige plus on a 5 wt. I think I read on here that those were made by okuma. That was also a good reel, but didn't look as good.