The main issue will be how you design the head. All are good and you'll get different opinions but personally, I don't recommend deer hair. Too much work; too much mess; not the best floatability. To be sure, deer hair flies are beautiful when finished and, if you enjoy spinning hair (I don't anymore), by all means try a few.
My recommendation would be to utilize pre-formed popper heads. These come in soft and hard versions. The soft ones can be colored with sharpie pens but the hard ones require enamel or spray paint. I've got lots of acrylic paint and use it for both head types and seal with a clear finish. The main drawback to pre-formed heads is cost and requirement to use epoxy or superglue. I do 'em in batches and still think they're easier than deer hair. I also recommend the "pencil" popper head design as I often find that smallies like an elongated popper and they don't seem to swallow long poppers as much as small, more rounded body types.
You can also experiment with sheet foam and design various "gurgler" type surface flies.
Keep the wings and fur part of the fly sparse. I rarely bother with rubber legs or hackle unlesss you really want to bulk it up.
The pics shows some poppers i tied recently with painted heads. These versions are for saltwater, use a shorter tail for bass poppers.